Build a Smarter, Leaner Pipeline That Actually Closes Deals
Rethinking the “More Leads = More Growth” Myth
Every sales leader, CEO, and growth-focused executive knows the pressure to keep the pipeline full. There’s a deeply ingrained belief that more leads equal more revenue, and it’s easy to see why. The more conversations you have, the more at-bats you get. The math seems simple.
But here’s the hard truth: not all leads are created equal. Some are nothing but distractions that can actively slow you down, drain your energy, and distract your team from real opportunities.
It’s like hauling a bunch of heavy rocks in your backpack up a steep hill. You’re moving, sure, but every step is harder, and the view from the top isn’t as clear. You might even find yourself sprinting to hit short-term goals, ignoring the long-term strain you’re putting on your team and the business.
Worse, the longer you cling to these low-quality leads, the more they distort your sense of what a real buyer looks like. You start mistaking politeness for interest, activity for progress, and curiosity for commitment. That’s when you get into real trouble.
Everyone in the organization (from sales reps to CROs to the CEO) needs to take ownership of defining, refining, and protecting the Ideal Customer Profile (ICP). If a lead doesn’t fit, it needs to go, no matter how tempting it is to keep them around.
When Pipeline Activity Masks Real Progress
When you’re juggling a dozen half-baked conversations, it’s easy to feel like you’re making progress. The meetings fill your calendar, the CRM is buzzing with activity, and your pipeline looks robust on paper. But the reality is, most of these leads are just dragging out the inevitable 'no' or, worse, a slow, painful ghosting that sucks your momentum.
Here’s what that usually looks like:
Your CRM is full, but your pipeline is weak – It’s a false sense of momentum. The numbers look good, but when you pressure test these leads, they crumble. You’re logging activity, but it’s not moving the needle.
Every call feels like a first call – You’re having the same surface-level conversations over and over. The buyer isn’t truly engaged. They’re ‘interested’ but not invested, and every call feels like you’re reintroducing yourself.
Follow-ups turn into a second job – You spend hours sending recap emails, chasing feedback, and trying to keep the spark alive in deals that should have closed or died weeks ago. You’re doing more nurturing than selling.
The 20% Cut That Unlocks the 80% That Matters
This isn’t about being harsh, it’s about being realistic. Some leads are never going to close, and keeping them around only distracts you from higher-quality prospects.
Here’s who to cut loose as you focus on building a smarter, leaner pipeline:
The 'Just One More Meeting' Crowd – These leads always need one more stakeholder’s opinion before moving forward. They drag you into endless loops without ever closing. You’ll hear things like, 'I just need to run this by my team' or 'Let me get a few more internal voices on this,' but those voices never make it to the call. They don’t lack interest; they lack the conviction to pull those folks in.
The Window Shoppers – They love the idea of your product but won’t commit. They nod along in meetings, ask for case studies, and seem enthusiastic, but never have a budget or a timeline. They’re more excited about the idea of change than actually making it.
The Budget Ghosts – If they can’t ballpark a budget or are clearly hoping you’ll cave on price, they’re not serious. They just want to benchmark you against competitors or justify their current vendor’s fees. If you find yourself justifying your price to someone who keeps hinting that your solution is 'a bit high for them,' cut them loose.
The Tire Kickers – They’re curious, maybe even complimentary, but they’re never going to buy. They show up to webinars, download white papers, and ask for demos to 'explore,' but dodge any question about budget or decision-making authority. They’re not looking for a solution, just information (which is fine, but they can also self-service through your website resources page).
Maintaining a High-Conviction Pipeline
Clearing out the above prospects is a good start, but keeping your pipeline clean is an ongoing discipline. It’s important to avoid time-wasters, but we also want to double down on the high-potential deals that are more likely to close.
Set a High Bar for Entry – Don’t let every interested party through the door. Use your gut check as a first filter. If a prospect can’t articulate their problem, has no timeline, or dodges budget questions, they don’t make the cut (yet).
Prune Regularly – Every sales rep should schedule a pipeline clean-up each month. Look for the warning signs we just covered above: vague next steps, constant rescheduling, or long gaps in communication. If it feels like you’re constantly restarting the conversation, it’s time to move on.
Invest in the Right 20% – With the extra bandwidth, you can now go deeper with the clients who actually have a shot. Focus on the ones who push for next steps, ask tough questions, and bring real decision-makers to the table. These are the deals that deserve your attention.
This Week: Make Space for Better Deals
Take a hard look at your pipeline. Cut five leads you know deep down aren’t going to close. The ones that drain your time, stall your momentum, or just feel off. Simply let them go.
Then go use that reclaimed energy to go all-in on five deals that do have a shot. Don’t just check in. Find a meaningful next move. Get creative. Reframe the value. Pull in a new stakeholder. Push for a real decision. When you focus on the right opportunities, things start to move.
Try it this week. Let me know what shifts.
📣 Support this work
This newsletter runs on real-world insight and real conversations. If it’s helping you pitch, position, or close smarter, you can now support the work.
→ Become a supporter